If you’re planning to stay in one of Barefoot Real Estate’s Point Pleasant Beach vacation rentals, your trip is sure to include some of the excellent dining options just a short drive away. While there are many Point Pleasant Beach restaurants in town, Cheyenne and Cali have extended their recommendations to a selection of eateries outside of town. From cozy breakfast spots to buzzy dinner destinations, these picks will undoubtedly elevate your getaway no matter where your culinary preferences lie.
Whether you’re booking Point Pleasant Beach summer rentals for a weekend escape or indulging in the luxury of Point Pleasant Beach house rentals with extended amenities, you’ll be poised to savor a diverse selection of flavors.
Breakfast
The Buttered Biscuit
One of Cheyenne’s favorite breakfast spots is The Buttered Biscuit in Bradley Beach. Known for its cozy ambiance and fresh ingredients, The Buttered Biscuit offers an exceptional start to your day. The menu is designed to appeal to a wide variety of tastes, but the standout item remains their biscuits, paired perfectly with freshly brewed coffee. For gluten-free eaters, The Buttered Biscuit also offers alternative menu options without compromising taste or texture. Its dedication to quality ingredients makes it an ideal choice for guests looking for great meals just outside Point Pleasant Beach.
Taylor Sam’s
Cali heads straight for Taylor Sam’s in Toms River when seeking a satisfying breakfast. Blending traditional breakfast fare with modern twists, Taylor Sam’s is a family-friendly restaurant that balances hearty portions with inventive flavor combinations. A fan favorite on the menu is the Vicious Biscuit, a breakfast sandwich made with a homemade cheddar jalapeno biscuit, pimento cheese, fried cauliflower doused in a hot honey glaze, and your choice of eggs. If you’re visiting Point Pleasant Beach, making a morning excursion to Taylor Sam’s should be on your list.
Lunch
Seed to Sprout
When lunch comes to mind, Cheyenne heads over to Seed to Sprout in Avon-by-the-Sea. This plant-based eatery emphasizes health-conscious eating with a creative and robust vegan menu. Their Hot Honee Toast, coupled with a fresh smoothie, is not only light but loaded with flavor. The restaurant’s locally sourced ingredients embrace sustainability and freshness, perfectly complementing an active beach lifestyle.
Windward Tavern
For Cali, lunch takes on a classic appeal at Windward Tavern in Brick Township. This establishment celebrates traditional American pub fare, offering timeless favorites such as burgers, sandwiches, and crisp salads. The inviting atmosphere gives lunch at Windward Tavern a warm sense of community, which makes it an excellent spot for family outings after mornings spent exploring the scenic waterfront areas.
Dinner
9th Ave Pier
Cheyenne’s dinner choice often brings her to 9th Ave Pier in Belmar, a restaurant with excellent waterfront views. With live music and an open-air setting, this vibrant restaurant offers a dynamic and lively dining experience. Seafood lovers will delight in the diverse options on the menu, from the raw bar to the excellent selection of sandwiches.
AP Rooftop
Cali enjoys her evenings at AP Rooftop in Asbury Park. Offering elevated dining with a spectacular view, AP Rooftop pairs exquisite dishes and innovative cocktails to create one of the most idyllic restaurants near Point Pleasant Beach. The upscale yet approachable environment appeals to couples and friends looking for an unforgettable night out.
Coffee
Turnstile Coffee Roasters
Cheyenne gets her caffeine fix at Turnstile Coffee Roasters. Located in Belmar, this roasting company crafts artisanal coffee that perfectly balances bold flavors with subtle undertones. Surrounded by inviting decor, this café offers more than coffee; it provides a brief retreat from sun-soaked days.
Divi Tree
Cali’s choice for coffee stops is Divi Tree in Toms River. A low-key yet vibrant coffee spot, this café specializes in drinks such as Colombian cold brew and delicious specialty lattes. The casual atmosphere nurtures productive work sessions or peaceful conversations, appealing to anyone who needs a warm yet rejuvenating dose of caffeine after long hours exploring the coastline.
Pizza
Vic’s Italian Restaurant
Cheyenne swears by Vic’s Italian Restaurant in Spring Lake when craving pizza outside Point Pleasant Beach. With authentic Italian recipes handed down over generations, Vic’s offers handcrafted thin-crust pizzas that evoke simplicity and excellence. Beyond pizza, its antipasto and pasta dishes round out an authentic Italian culinary experience.
Oakwood’s Point Pizza
Cali opts for Oakwood’s Point Pizza in Brick Township for her pizza fix. Praising its stone-baked pies and fresh toppings, the White Pizza showcases a perfect trifecta of flavor with ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic. Oakwood’s is also known for its welcoming service, adding a personable touch that delights individual customers and large families alike.
Plan Your Visit
There is so much to do and see around Point Pleasant Beach! Book one of our fabulous vacation rentals in Point Pleasant Beach today to discover your new favorite beach destination.
Ice Cream
Cookman Creamery
Cheyenne’s favorite sweet stop remains Cookman Creamery in Asbury Park. A vegan-friendly ice cream haven, Cookman prides itself on creating creamy and decadent options that are surprising yet delightful to everyone’s taste buds. With flavors ranging from Lemon Poppy Loaf to Espresso, this stop adds cheerful indulgence to any evening in Point Pleasant Beach.
Sundae’s
Meanwhile, Cali ventures to Sundae’s in Manasquan for traditional yet expertly-made ice cream. Expect classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate, along with specialty treats such as their Cannoli Sundaes. Travelling families will find Sundae’s to be a memorable outing for children and adults alike.
Where To Stay in Point Pleasant Beach
From vibrant restaurants to cozy coffee shops and sweet stops, exploring the culinary options just outside Point Pleasant Beach adds exciting variety to any vacation. Barefoot Real Estate ensures that your stay is both comfortable and convenient by offering Point Pleasant Beach vacation rentals in prime locations. Whether you’re booking Point Pleasant Beach summer rentals for seasonal visits or seeking Point Pleasant Beach house rentals to accommodate extended family trips, our range of properties fits any need. For those who prefer a touch of luxury, Point Pleasant vacation rentals with a pool combine relaxing amenities with proximity to the region’s finest dining options, ensuring every guest can enjoy both effortless comfort and unforgettable local flavors. Block out your dates and make the most of your time exploring the area—great food and even greater accommodations are waiting!